Best small cars for new drivers

Are you a new driver looking for your first car? Whatever your budget, find the best small car to get you on the road.

There are many factors to consider when picking out a car, let alone your first car. Many young(er) and first-time drivers are choosing small cars, but why?

Small cars are generally a great gateway into the world of driving, after all, it can be a bit of a bumpy road to passing your test!

First cars are traditionally cheap to run and have low insurance costs. They need to be easy to drive without compromising on practicality, safety, tech or good looks.

Typically, I went for a car with high insurance costs. But it had no road tax and was amazing on fuel – it’s all about finding that balance and what you can afford.

Many small cars offer all these perks, no matter your budget. After all, good things come in small packages (I say being 5ft3 myself).

But let’s not get into my height, what are the best small cars for new drivers? What are their reliability? And which ones are affordable to insure and run?

Let’s dive straight in.

Audi A1

While the Audi A1 may be a more premium option, it has an amazing balance of practicality and sportiness, while also being surprisingly affordable. However, I may be biased as my first car was an Audi A1.

The quote 'Though she be but little she is fierce' perfectly sums up the Audi A1—compact, yet packs a punch!

My friends referred to my car as ‘the opposite of the Tardis.’

It’s small on the outside, but once you're in, you’re wondering where the rest of the car is. So, if you’re on the taller side of life, this car probably won’t suit you – it might cramp your style.

Despite its size, it is most definitely fierce. Put your foot down slightly and you’re gone.

However, if you’re looking for low road tax, amazing fuel efficiency, and a stylish car, the Audi A1 is for you. Insurance, on the other hand, is higher than other cars in this blog.

SKODA Fabia

The Fabia range can be little or large, depending on your choice—but don’t let that fool you, it’s got plenty of punch for its size. We will look at the hatchback as this is the smaller of the two.

It’s the ‘quiet achiever’ of the SKODA range.

While the Octavia and Kamiq steal the spotlight, the Fabia’s quietly rocking it as the reliable, low-insurance sidekick. With it also being ranked as the third cheapest car to insure for new drivers in 2024, according to RAC.

With a 52-56 mile per gallon (mpg) fuel efficiency, it’s not too shabby on fuel either.

Volkswagen Golf

If there’s a hatchback that’s truly driven through the ages, it’s the Volkswagen Golf. Since its launch in 1974, the Golf has evolved into a modern marvel, combining high-end quality, efficiency, and practicality.

With its powerful engine and sleek design, the Golf is a hatchback for those who enjoy life in the fast lane.

But if you’re looking for reliability, it’s unfortunately listed as one of the most unreliable cars, according to WhatCar. However, the Volkswagen Golf is a true fan favourite, and has gained popularity over its long lifespan.

After all, when a car’s been around this long, it must be doing something right, whether that’s wowing drivers with its practicality, performance, or timeless design.

Plus, with its slightly larger size, the Golf often graduates from “first car” to “family hero.” You’ll find plenty of these trusty old hatchbacks ferrying kids, dogs, and the weekly shop—proof that while it might stall in reliability surveys, it’s not stalling in popularity.

Vauxhall Corsa

Joining the Volkswagen Golf on the list of the unfortunately unreliable cars is the Corsa, yet it’s a small car that has been synonymous with younger drivers – but why if it’s “unreliable”, I hear you asking?

Joining the Golf in the “unreliable but lovable” club is the Vauxhall Corsa. It's the small car that has become a go-to for younger drivers, even if it occasionally needs a little TLC.

While it might not have the best reliability score, the Corsa is like that friend who always shows up late but still makes the best party entrance. Everyone loves them, and their flaws.

Generally, it’s cheaper to run than other cars. On top of this, it’s easy to drive and comfortable – while also being stylish and affordable to buy.

So you can see why younger new drivers love the Vauxhall Corsa.

SEAT Ibiza

Hitting the scene in 1984, the SEAT Ibiza, brought a splash of Spanish flair to the hatchback world.

Not quite as seasoned as the Volkswagen Golf, but it’s still a classic fan-favourite—and further proof that good things do come in small packages (and at a competitive price!).

Despite being around longer than most of its drivers, the SEAT Ibiza is often overlooked by younger and new drivers. But when you compare it to its rivals, you’ll realize it’s like finding a hidden tapas bar—great value, packed with surprises, and absolutely worth the hype.

While its design may not scream “sporty,” it’s stylish enough to turn heads, and the spacious cabin, impressive tech, and wealth of safety features more than make up for it. In fact, the Ibiza’s commitment to safety scored it top marks in its Euro NCAP safety rating.

Kia Picanto

Sneaking onto our list is the small and sprightly Kia Picanto.

Cheap to run, cheap to insure, and big on charm, the Picanto is a dream come true for new drivers on a tight budget—because let’s face it, we’re not all made of money (as much as we wish we were).

Capable of nearly 60mpg, the Kia Picanto is incredibly efficient and economical, making it a match made in heaven for first-time drivers.

Affordable? Absolutely.

Economical? You bet.

But what about reliable? No surprise here, another yes.

Ranked number five on WhatCar’s list of the most reliable cars, the Picanto checks every box for new drivers looking for a practical, budget-friendly option with a dash of personality.

Fiat 500

Looking for a cheap-to-insure, small-but-stylish car that’s as funky as it is functional? Enter the Fiat 500.

Joining the likes of the Kia Picanto and SKODA Fabia on the list of the cheapest cars to insure for new drivers, the Fiat 500 combines retro charm with modern flair. It’s the kind of car that turns heads, without turning your wallet inside out.

Practicality? It’s got you covered. With 185 litres of boot space, it’s perfect for your day-to-day errands.

Need to pack a little more? Drop the back seats to boost your space to a generous 550 litres. And if you’ve still got a friend tagging along, the 50:50 split option means you can carry both cargo and company.

It’s like a clown car, but chic.

Perfect for zipping through town or squeezing into tight parking spots, the Fiat 500 is a city-driving superstar. Who said practicality couldn’t be stylish?

Ford Fiesta

Ah, the Ford Fiesta—an absolute classic. It’s like the favourite band you just can’t stop listening to, even if they’ve stopped making new albums.

Ford may have waved goodbye to Fiesta production in 2022, but this little legend remains a top choice for new drivers.

Why? Because it’s as reliable as your mum texting “drive safe!” the moment you leave the house.

Easy to drive, budget-friendly, and with a five-star Euro NCAP safety rating, the Fiesta has all the right moves to make you feel confident behind the wheel.

While new Fiestas are getting rarer than a sunny bank holiday, it’s still a solid option if you’re exploring used car deals.

Hyundai i10

Last but by no means least, we have the Hyundai i10—a pint-sized powerhouse that’s kind on your wallet and perfect for new drivers.

Topping the list of the cheapest cars for new drivers to insure, this supermini proves that getting on the road doesn’t have to break the bank.

Despite its compact size, the Hyundai i10 is full of surprises. With 252 litres of boot space, it’s got room for your shopping, gym bag, or a couple of small suitcases for that weekend escape.

Who says you can’t pack a punch in a small package?

With stable handling and precise steering, the i10 is as comfortable winding through narrow country lanes as it is zipping around town. Add to that its affordable running costs, and you’ve got a car that’s as practical as it is dependable.

Time to Choose: The Best Small Cars for New Drivers

You never forget your first car – trust me, I personally wish I could have my Audi A1 back. But alas, a buggy just doesn't fit in the boot. Speaking from experience here!

Budgets may vary, but finding the sweet spot between safety, reliability, and affordability is key. It’s a very personal choice, so be sure to do your homework.

What do you need?

What do you want?

The right car is out there, you just have to find it.

And if you’re over 18, leasing is a great option to get a better car for a more affordable monthly cost – you could be driving something you didn’t think was in your budget.

Why settle when you could cruise in style, right?

Hopefully, this list has made your decision a little easier – we know how mind-numbing the research process can be (we’ve all been there, scrolling endlessly and questioning life choices).